• I once wrote a book about Wim Wenders.  It covered the first 20 years of his career, his breakout years in Germany, where he became one of the luminaries of the New German Cinema, which sought to separate itself from the mostly mediocre studio films of Germany’s postwar economic-miracle era, and his foray into American filmmaking, a rocky period which, nevertheless, culminated in the highly successful collaboration with Sam Shepherd on Paris, Texas (1984).  In a recent interview with NPR, Wenders noted that critics characterized these years by three A’s: angst, alienation, and America, and that’s not a bad summation.  The angst was always male; women, if they appeared in the films at all, inspired the intensest angst.  Relationships never worked out (on or off screen).  Wenders collaborated with Peter Handke, a more disciplined, but even more alienated artist, on many of the German films.  They were slow and contemplative and asked more questions than they answered.  Composed of inner journeys and outer landscapes more than real stories, they anticipated Wenders’ eventual turn to documentary, as many of them were already quasi-documentaries.  Kings of the Road (1976) documented the last of Germany’s rural movie theaters; Lightning Over Water (1980), supposed to be a collaboration with Nicolas Ray on a last movie, ended up documenting Ray’s last days, while The State of Things (1982), though fiction, chronicled the all-too-real dilemma of a film crew stuck with an unworkable project.

    Although preceded by two short films for French television, the delightful, Chris-Marker-like Tokyo-ga (1985), represents Wenders’ first notable foray into documentary.  The film explores idiosyncratic aspects of Japanese culture on the way to finding out more about Wenders’ hero (and mine), Japanese filmmaker Yasujiro Ozu.  Another decade of both fictional and documentary films followed, culminating in three Academy Award nominations for Best Documentary: The Buena Vista Social Club (1999), Pina (2011), and, this past season, Salt of the Earth (2014).

    With Salt of the Earth Wenders has achieved his most compelling work to date.  A chronicle of the life and work of Brazilian photographer Sebastião Salgado, the film takes us through Salgado’s short-lived beginnings as a revolutionary, which effectively exiled him from Brazil for a decade, his decision to give up a comfortable life as an economist to become a photographer, and the many photo projects he embarked on, projects that increasingly centered on the world’s marginalized.  The title “Salt of the Earth” is also the title of the 1954 Herbert Biberman fiction film about a strike by mine workers in New Mexico.  In early interviews Wenders sometimes named the Biberman film as one of his favorites, though his inward-looking early films gave little indication of own interest in such subject matter.  

    As chronicled by Wenders, Salgado’s photo career reaches a literal dead end when he photographs the Rwandan genocide and its less publicized aftermath, the death by starvation or disease of hundreds of thousands of Hutus, expelled from Rwanda when the Tutsis regained power.  Emotionally and artistically exhausted, Salgado returns to his father’s farm, where he grew up.  It too has been devastated—by drought and poor farming methods—but, together with his wife and life partner Lélia, Salgado successfully replants a rainforest, tiny tree by tiny tree, and the couple establishes the Instituto Terra (earth institute) on the farm, which has since become a national park, to teach others how to restore devastated land.  The reclamation project restores Salgado’s faith in living, and he goes on to become a nature photographer, giving to these images the same breath-taking depth, beauty, and grittiness that had characterized his earlier work, continuing to travel the world and risk his life—as the film documents when the crew has to crawl on its collective belly to elude a polar bear while Salgado photographs walruses in the Arctic.

    In creating the film, Wenders collaborated with Salgado’s son Juliano Ribeiro Salgado, who accompanied his father on the later expeditions recorded in the film, both to get footage for his own film and to get to know his so often absent father better.  The collaboration with Wenders, the young with the old, was, according to both men, difficult, and editing alone took about 18 months.  However, struggling through hours of footage and differing visions of how to shape the film eventually brought the depth, breadth, intensity, and plenitude that characterize the end product.    

    The film is structured around ever-widening circles of family (something a young Wenders found difficult to believe in).  First, there are the three generations of the Salgado family, central to which is the life-long love affair and partnership between Sebastião and Lélia that endures constant separation, yet survives and flourishes; next the human family that Sebastião photographs in all its variety, pathos, and savagery; and finally the family of all living things, at the same time fragile and resilient.  No more angst, alienation, or America.  Wenders confidently embraces the world in this rich, mature, affirmative work of art.

    Wim Wenders2 copy

    Wim Wenders, 1980's

     

  • This is a searingly beautiful account of Catherine Raven’s journey from alienation to healing through the ministrations of an unusual wild fox.  Raven is a survivor, a hardy soul from a dysfunctional family, highly intelligent, acutely sensitive, and brutally honest.  Trained as a biologist, she rambles through an eclectic sampling of natural history and her own observations while attaching them to carefully chosen if idiosyncratic selections from literature: Mary Shelley, Herman Melville, Lafcadio Hearn, and, especially, Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, whose Little Prince she reads aloud to the fox (!).  Why, she asks, is mankind so detached from the natural world?  Why do we push it away, relegating it to “scientific scrutiny” (and too often wanton destruction) instead of viewing and nurturing it with the totality of our humanity?  A question ever more relevant as we stand on the brink of losing so much of this world…  Raven’s helplessness in the face of a wildfire from which she cannot save Fox seems emblematic of our present struggles.  Her ability to move past his death and pull together the fragmented strands of her life should give us hope and, perhaps, suggest a way forward.

     

    Fox

     

     

  • Spielberg’s West Side Story is a thrill to watch with its gritty realism and wonderfully creative dance numbers set against a decaying New York City in the late 50s.  But it is more sociological treatise than Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet.  In the midst of a “slum clearance” project, loser white guys try to thwart the progress of aspirational newcomers with brown skin.  (Raise your hands if this sounds familiar.)  Jets’ leader Riff is a psychopath, not a teen who has yet to grow up, while Tony is a teen who has spent time in prison for almost killing an adversary in a fight.  One critic faults this backstory for positing prison as a positive experience (as if no one ever reforms in prison and, even if they do, we should never admit it).  But the real problem with Tony’s backstory is that, having almost killed someone in the past, his killing Bernardo in the rumble becomes inevitable rather than the result of a single, tragic moment of revenge.  All of which undermines the love story, which is the core of both Shakespeare’s play and the original West Side Story. 

                Tony and Maria’s “wedding night” lacks both romance and poignancy, knowing, as we do, that Tony, for all his efforts to reform, is still a killer.  The couple seems doomed less from the gang rivalry and hatred that surround them than from Tony’s inability to overcome his killer instinct.  It’s no accident that the song “There’s a Place for Us” has been taken from the lovers and given to Rita Moreno as the matriarchal widow of the original film’s Doc because there really is no place Tony can go to escape his crime, a fact driven home by the frequent police presence in the film.

                The love story is further eroded by the fact that Anita and Bernardo are not simply lovers but live together (along with Maria).  In the original play/movie they parallel Tony and Maria and act as a foil to the young lovers—the more carnal couple vs. the innocent, romantic one. This not only undermines Anita’s part of the four-part “Tonight,” in which she imagines hot sex with Bernardo after the rumble, but makes her “I Have a Love” duet with Maria unbelievable as well.  Her grief is that of a wife, not a girlfriend.  (We even see her in the morgue identifying Bernardo’s body.)  How can she forgive so easily?

                The two songs that should work to build up the love story, “I Feel Pretty” and  “One Hand, One Heart,” which in the original follow upon one another in the intimacy of the dress-making shop (which in Spielberg’s film has been moved to Anita’s apartment), have been separated, the “wedding” song to the Cloisters, a tourist destination, and “I Feel Pretty” to a large department store, where Maria is part of the night cleaning crew. Jarringly, the “I Feel Pretty” sequence occurs immediately after Riff and Bernardo have been killed in the rumble. 

                As I watched the film I kept thinking how artificial, on so many levels, the original movie seemed, but towards the end, as Shakespeare’s series of unlikely coincidences kicked in, I realized that Spielberg’s realism could not sustain the disbelief Shakespeare’s story requires.  His fable has a simple but universal moral: hate kills love and everything beautiful in this world.  Spielberg’s version tells us that gentrification, resentful white men, psychotic personalities, and the abuse of firearms screw things up for everyone.  Tragedy gives way to a complex of social problems.  (The original film acknowledges social problems but confines them to two humorous songs, “Officer Krupke” and “I Want to Be in America.”)

                For pure cinematic pleasure, see Spielberg’s West Side Story, but don’t expect a Shakespearean tragedy of thwarted love but rather a catalogue of social dysfunction that feels all too familiar—which is the point of this movie.  For Shakespeare’s story, see the old version and revel in its theatricality.  And don’t be too censorious of Natalie Wood and George Chakiris in brownface.  (Before being cast as Bernardo in the movie, Chakiris played Riff in the London stage production.)  Just remember, the very first Juliet was played by a man.  (Nobody’s perfect!) West Side Story

     

     

  •  

    Book.image
    In 2017 I decided to write a book about the Japanese filmmaker Yasujiro Ozu, and I spent the next three years closely analyzing his 33 extant films along with 3 fragments, researching the historical background, and catching up with what other scholars had written.  I had been writing about Ozu since 1983, and my most recent article was published in 2010.  That article went into the book almost unchanged, but, in fact, every article I had ever written about him went in in some form, sometimes as only a paragraph or a single sentence, along with material from my earlier book on Wim Wenders and some of my research on Hollywood’s 1950s films about Japan.  But much of my analysis was new, and most of the older material was rethought, revised, and updated.  I critiqued previous authors, whose work other scholars had let stand, when I thought parts of it did not hold up under close scrutiny.  I nevertheless benefitted greatly from the research and insights of many of those same authors as well as material from many others.  Among those I leaned on most were David Bordwell, Peter B. High, Kyoko Hirano, Tadao Sato, Mitsuyo Wada-Marciano, and historians John Dower and Ben-Ami Shillony.  Anthologies on Asian film in general and Ozu in particular also proved a wonderful resource, particularly one edited by Jinhee Choi and those by edited by David Desser (with or without colleagues).

     I finished the first draft just as the pandemic struck and was able to spend the next six months revising without interruption, thanks to the pandemic lockdown.  Securing a publisher took another six months, but, finally, in April of 2021, Hong Kong University Press snapped up the manuscript proposal, toward which American presses had been fairly indifferent.  I spent the entire next year revising, editing, gathering illustrations, and creating an index. Finally, in June of 2022, Ozu: A Closer Look rolled off the presses and arrived at my house.  I approached the package apprehensively, like a new mom hoping her child had all its fingers and toes, but I needn’t have worried.  HKUP did a beautiful job and continues to be a delight to work with.

    The book is divided into three parts.  The first takes up issues concerning Ozu’s silent films, including a close analysis of his three “gangster” films, the symbolism he used in his silent period, how he pictured sound in these films, and how he structured narrative.  In Part II I looked at his first ten sound films, which were made as Japan’s war with China intensified then morphed into a war with the United States, followed by the American Occupation of Japan, which lasted until 1952.  Each of these films finds Ozu endorsing the policies of whichever government was in a position to censor them while at the same time offering subtle critiques and sometimes mocking those same governments.

     Part III takes up specific themes that pertain to all of the films but particularly those later, mainly color films from the 1950s and early 60s that closed out Ozu’s career.  These themes include narrative strategies and meaning in his late films, his take on gender issues and religion, the extent to which other two-dimensional art forms in Japan (i.e. painting and printmaking) influenced or coincided formally, thematically, and ideologically with his work, and, finally, a discussion of a selection of specific films and filmmakers whose work was influenced by Ozu. 

    This book concludes my decades of work on Ozu, whose films will never get old.  I hope it will prove a valuable companion for those wanting deeper insight into the filmmaker and his films and that it, too, will stand the test of time.

     

     

  • The first of at least four films paying tribute to old movie theaters, The Last Picture Show (Peter Bogdanovich, 1971) involves a relationship between a middle-aged woman (Cloris Leachman) and a teenaged boy (Timothy Bottoms).  Sam Mendes has updated the story to a tourist town on England’s South Coast in the 1980s.  Stephen (Michael Ward), who is Black, is trying to get into college when he takes a job at the local movie palace, whose upper floors are shuttered.  He begins an affair with co-worker Hillary (Olivia Colman), a mentally fragile, middle-aged woman, whose love-life consists of having sex with their married boss (Colin Firth) in his office.  Stephen frees Hillary from that bad relationship, but his own with her has no future, either.  Shattered when Stephen breaks off their sexual liaison, Hillary must find her way to a more appropriate friendship with the ever-loyal Stephen, who is forced to face down discrimination and violence on his way to being accepted into college.

    The film moves slowly, punctuated by two loud and jarring episodes: Hillary’s breakdown upon Stephen’s withdrawal from their affair and the attack on Stephen, in the theater, by a group of skinheads; both involve the violent smashing in of doors.  Parallels, in fact, structure the film: Hillary’s two affairs; the “family” of theater workers, frequently shown sitting around the table in their break room, and Stephen’s small family, also shown sitting at their kitchen table; Hillary’s dead but formerly philandering father and her boss; Stephen’s absent father and the projectionist’s confession that he, too, had run out on his wife and son.  These parallels anchor the story and, along with its evocation of goodwill and tolerance, keep it from floating away on the tides of Hillary’s mercurial personality even as its strength comes from the uncompromising depiction of her instability

  • Ozu- A Closer Look by Kathe Geist

    If you haven't read the book but you'd like to see the movie, here is the link: https://youtu.be/lISq-7bID94

     

  • World War II left millions of children wounded, homeless, hungry, impoverished and often orphaned in defeated and victorious countries alike, as the V-mail below attests.  In the United States, the kids were, for the most part, all right, although the stress and dislocation of the war years left some homeless, as a youthful Maya Angelou discovers in I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings.  But impoverished or not, universally, across the globe, children waited for their fathers to come home.

    My sister Gretel was born within a fortnight of the bombing of Pearl Harbor, and for most of her first four years my father was a soldier. 

    G&D Gretel and Dad.1

    He was discharged from the Army in the fall of 1945 after spending five months in London interrogating German POWs . He reunited with his tiny family at my grandmother’s house in Buffalo since the Army did not house dependents once soldiers were deployed overseas (which may explain why some kids ended up homeless).  Removing his officer’s hat, he threw it on the floor, emphatically declaring, “I’m done with the Army!”–at which point my sister burst into tears!  In her mind his Army uniform was as much a part of him as his mustache.

    V-Mail '45.1
    V-Mail from London, June, 1945, from my father to my sister, describing a little girl in ragged clothing, hoping for some chewing gum from American soldiers


    Kids on VE Day.3

    Children’s parade on V.E. Day (May 8, 1945) in San Antonio, TX.  Gretel is pushing a baby carriage; the boy behind her rides a tricycle, and the child behind him carries a watering can; the boy in front carries the flag.


  • Io Capitanopix

    In a year of good films, Io Capitano [I Captain] stands out as both incredibly moving and well-crafted.  It is the story of two teenaged cousins who leave their home in Senegal, hoping for a better life in Europe.  Their dreams are big, but their ignorance and naiveté are way bigger.  Italy is their intended destination, but first they must get to Tripoli in Northern Africa.  They encounter unspeakable horrors on the way, and we, the audience, keep wondering if they will succeed in their ambitions or be crushed.  What judgment will the film render on their decision to leave against their mothers’ protestations and the advice of far wiser minds?  But this is not where this brilliant script and amazing acting takes us.  Conned into piloting a rickety boat filled to over capacity with other refugees, the boy Seydou shouts at the helicopter hoving over their craft off the coast of Sicily “I’m the captain!  I saved everyone!  No one died!”

                No one died.  This is the outstanding achievement.  Seydou has retained his humanity in the face of unbearable inhumanity.  Thinking back we should have seen this coming: Seydou turning back to help a woman dying in the desert, his refusal to leave Tripoli without his cousin Moussa.  And he in turn benefits from the kindness of others.  An older man, a skilled laborer, temporarily “adopts” him, saving his life; a refugee physician treats Moussa’s wounded leg and helps Seydou to procure black market drugs for his cousin.

                Our expectation that the film produce a resolution regarding the boys’ ambitions are, of course, justified.  This is a journey film, a road movie, a buddy film, a quest narrative, a literary form as old as Western literature itself.  And part of the boys’ dream is realized: they reach Europe.  But whether they will find a better life, whether the harrowing journey was worth it, these questions are never answered, and we are left instead with the understanding that how one journeys is as important as the goal: “I saved everyone; no one died!”

     

     

  • *Fam Portrait2Kathe and Steve at home with Rocky, Pepper and over a dozen home-grown pumpkins!

    Mill Brook House, vacation spot and part-time rental, is now our permanent home!  Nellie Fox, the fierce shiba inu, is no longer with us and neither is lovable Sandy, champion mouser, whom we acquired soon after Nellie’s passing.  Rocky, once half of the Sandy-Rocky show, continues to enjoy the great outdoors as does Pepper, our mini-Australian sheepdog.  In 2016, they were joined by baby Max, another yellow tabby.  (Sadly, Max left us prematurely, and we adopted baby Taz in 2023.) Taz

    Max7_edited-1

    Mill Brook House, first renovated (2004-2006) to accommodate vacationers, has, more recently, undergone renovations to make our permanent residence possible.  We have extended the loft over our attached, two-part garage, built a staircase to the attic and a large new closet on what was once a spacious landing, completed a new guest room with its own closet (a rare commodity in this house), constructed a massive bookcase in the living room where we once tucked a trundle bed, further improved the downstairs bathroom, ditched the 1920's kitchen sink, and turned the downstairs bedroom into a glorified pantry.  To the swimming-pool-turned-garden from 2004, we added a second garden when Hurricane Irene made re-landscaping necessary, and in 2015 we built a third garden dedicated to gladioli and vegetables.  We have also launched a daylily business (see millbrookhousedaylilies.com). 

    Millbrookhousenews.com will continue to offer insights and information on Western Massachusetts, occasional film and relevant book reviews, our photographs of the area, including wildlife, landscapes, and landmarks, and personal essays.  Recipes have been spun off onto their own blog, millbrookhouserecipes.com.  For more of Steve's photographs, see sternbachphoto.com. We hope that you will enjoy all four blogs!  You can comment right on the blogs or email us at foxacres12@gmail.com.  

    New House Photo1 Blog
    Mill Brook House, summer 2013

     

  • In John Ford’s enormously seminal film The Searchers (1956), two men spend five years searching for a young girl who has been abducted by Indians. When they find her, she has entered her teens and become one of the chief’s wives. At first she declares her allegiance to the tribe but later changes her mind and agrees to return home with the men. The reasons for her change of heart are never explained, nor did they need to be for a 1950’s audience. The girl had obviously come to her senses, remembered her past, and realized the advantages of returning to “civilization.” Such was not the case, however, with most white women captured as children and raised up in Indian tribes. Spinning

    One of the best documented cases is that of Eunice Williams, daughter of a prominent Puritan clergyman, who, with her father and brother, was captured in the 1704 raid on Deerfield, Massachusetts, by Mohawk Indians and their French allies and marched 300 miles to Montreal through deep snow. The raid was a small piece of the War of the Spanish Succession—the one that made Winston Churchill’s ancestor Lord Marlborough famous—which had spilled over onto the American continent. The raid took place before dawn on February 29 and is commemorated every leap year by the Pocumtuck Valley Memorial Association. (Pocumtuck is the name both natives and colonists used for Deerfield at one time.)

    This year’s commemorative events included lectures, reenactments, and demonstrations of colonial housekeeping crafts.

    Cooking

     Re-enactors, many of whom had come considerable distance, staged the battle that took place after the attack on Deerfield when militiamen from Northampton and other nearby settlements, seeing flames, marched to Deerfield and engaged the French and Indians as the last of them were leaving the burning village. Turned back by an ambush, the militiamen were unable to rescue any of the captives. This year about twenty re-enactors, pretending to be Frenchmen, English colonials, Mohawk and Abenaki, stood in for what had been a battle involving about 300 men. This left much to the imagination, but a narrator helpfully told the story while the actors “did battle” on a field at the Deerfield Academy.

    Militia_edited-1

    As for Eunice Williams, although her father and brother were eventually “redeemed” (ransomed) and returned to Deerfield, she never went home. Captured specifically to take the place of a Mohawk child who had died, and converted to Catholicism by her Indian family, who lived in close proximity to the French, she refused every attempt by her father and brother to persuade her to return. As a teenager, she fell in love with a fellow tribesman, and, although dubious about the inter-racial union, the local padre married them when they declared they would live together unwed if he did not. Throughout his life, her brother, a clergyman like his father and tortured by fears for her immortal soul, wrote to and of her, and, on occasion, she and her husband visited him, pitching their tent in his yard in preference to sleeping in the house. Eunice herself remained illiterate, so we have no record of what she actually thought about her life with the Mohawk, although her actions speak quite loudly.

    For more on Eunice Williams and the conundrum she posed for her family, see John Demos, The Unredeemed Captive (1994). To observe the next commemoration of the 1704 raid on Deerfield, you’ll have to wait until 2020.